Cinema Vérité
We are always on the verge of love and always on the verge of being alone — Milan Kundera
If one believes in astrology, as Miguel does, they would understand the attributes of an Aquarius. Claire is an Aquarius, and over the past week she is revealing some of those attributes. Retreating, silence, turning within herself, closing off. This is what Miguel uses to justify his confusion. For the past week, he has not heard from her. No phone calls. No texts. No social media shares. He fears he’s being ghosted again. Was it the scene from the screenplay he had read to her? Was it pushing the issue regarding the relationship with her father? Was it something else he’d done inadvertently? He’s down the rabbit hole again, even when trying to distract himself with work. It isn’t helping. More phone calls. More texts. Silence. What was it that she said about silence?
The first three days were unbearable. After that, a sort of tacit resignation set in. He did his best to get on with his life. By the end of the week, he felt the need to get out of the apartment, take in a good film. Maybe it will inspire him to write an essay about it for his website. But not the Cinémathèque Français.
He stands on a misty Rue Champollion. There’s a chill in the air. He turns up his collar against the windswept rain, the kind of rain which feels like it seeps into your bones. His coat and shoes are soaked as he waits in line at the Filmothéque du Quartier Latin. The small neon sign above the entrance flickers a pale blue light on his face. They’re showing an Èric Rohmer film. One of his favorites. It’s a favorite of Claire’s as well. They’d discussed it many times. He’s having second thoughts now. Perhaps Love in The Afternoon is not the right film to indulge in. He perseveres. It’s better than sitting alone in his apartment delving into his own erratic mind. Still, he can’t help thinking about Claire. She should be with him. He’s less worried that he upset her than he is that she’s out with someone else. Maybe that was the reason for her sudden silence. He’d rather her be upset with him. He keeps peering down the alley-like street in the off chance he’ll see her emerge from the mist. Life is not an Èric Rohmer film, however.
The line inches forward. He shivers in the cold rain. His eyes scan the darkened street with the hope that this time it will turn into an Èric Rohmer film. Other than those braving such a miserable evening as this, not a soul stirs on the narrow thoroughfare. It’s beginning to feel like a vice, closing in on him. He checks his cellphone. Nothing. He eyes the couples on the line, those youthful faces who look happy, who are not going to experience the film alone like he is. He never minded taking in a film by himself. This time is different.
. . . . . .
Miguel arrived in Paris last winter. It was not a romantic winter, but one of broken dates, lonely walks, and insufferable cold. This forced him inside the cafés rather than having his coffee on the terraces. It was a far cry from the romantic images he held dear before he left Lima, hopefully for good. It was a winter of discontent, trying to become acclimated in his new job as a copy editor at a prestigious cinema magazine. Finding an affordable apartment also proved difficult but he eventually found one, in the heart of the tenth arrondissement. It’s primarily an immigrant neighborhood. It might not have been the Latin Quarter, Montmartre, or Montparnasse, but this is what his salary dictated.
Come Spring, he found himself a little more settled, though no less alone. He spent most of his time working and haunting the cafés around the Latin Quarter. There he’d write his essays on film for his website dedicated to cinema, or work on his burgeoning screenplay. Sometimes he’d do his day work, struggling to meet the rigid deadlines his employers inflicted upon him. He tried to make the most of these unexpected compromises.
To break the monotony, he often attended screenings at the Cinémathèque Français, which frequently showed his favorite films. His visits to the theater had less to do with his passion for cinema than it was an antidote to his insufferable loneliness. There he could sit in the dark, turn off for awhile, and silence the persistent voices in his head which often taunted him for making the impulsive decision to leave Lima for Paris. He was essentially starting from scratch in a culture completely alien to his own. It allowed him to prevent continuously falling down the rabbit hole of his ever present anxiety. The cinema allows for this kind of distraction.
There was another reason for attending these screenings as often as he did. Claire.
Claire frequented the Cinémathèque Français as often as he did. Always alone, usually sitting far across the theater, hidden in the darkness. Her occasional visibility revealed itself in the flickering light of the projection screen. Miguel wanted to sit closer to her, but she always arrives after he did. He had to make do watching her from afar. He promised himself one day he was going to muster up the courage to speak to her. That opportunity arrived during a screening of Last Year at Marienbad. He finally summoned up his courage. He approached her.
. . . . . .
Claire does not have a creative career. She works in a medical office. Claire is not an artist. Miguel didn’t mind. There was never any prerequisite that a love interest had to be an artist. Claire is French, born and raised in the suburbs of Paris. Her love for cinema is as passionate as his own. She is a lovely young woman with blonde hair and blue eyes, with just a hint of freckles splayed across the bridge of her nose. She carried herself with a particular elegance and grace which Miguel found intensely alluring. She is the complete opposite of those he had grown accustomed to. Perhaps that, too, was part of her appeal. She reminded him of Catherine Deneuve.
Being that Miguel’s profession required him to be fluent in French, they had no issues communicating. Claire often found his Peruvian-accented French, if not sometimes difficult to understand, rather endearing. Though Miguel didn’t necessarily fly the Peruvian flag, he did write his essays and burgeoning screenplay in Spanish. He often translated his work into French for her. She enjoyed what he wrote and they shared the same tastes and cinematic sensibilities. She was an answered prayer.
They began spending time together, though not as often as Miguel would have liked. They were, technically, good friends. No intimacy had yet occurred. Claire helped alleviate his loneliness. Miguel, in turn, did the same for her.
They mostly spoke on the phone or sent text messages to one another. They even shared film clips through social media. When they did meet in person, it was usually in a specific café in Belleville, where Claire shared an apartment with one of her coworkers. They never spent time at her apartment, nor at his. Always the same café. These conversations allowed them to unburden themselves, to relieve their respective loneliness, and find a peculiar solace in sharing stories of absence. Rarely were there stories of joy — unless it had to do with cinema.
. . . . . .
Autumn. Paris had taken on a veneer of russet, reds, browns, and yellows. The atmosphere had done a lot to lift Miguel out of his ever present doldrums. The air was crisp, cool. The smells were different. He felt more inspired by the progress of his screenplay. The only downside was not seeing Claire as much as he liked.
On one crisp autumn Sunday, they agreed to meet at the café in Belleville. On the way to the café, which required a metro ride, it occurred to him that there were still a lot of question marks surrounding Claire. How well did he really know her? This often kept him up at night. He had often been an open book. She remained closed, guarded, full of secrets and mysteries. He opened up to her in ways he’d never dare open up with anyone else. It left him feeling vulnerable. Claire, meanwhile, remained behind her fortress, only occasionally lowering the drawbridge across the mote.
. . . . . .
Sitting at their usual table under the awning at the far end of the terrace, the wind sweeping the dead leaves up the sidewalk, Miguel read her the latest scene from his burgeoning screenplay, translating it into French as he read.
‘That’s very intense,’ she told him.
‘It’s based on my relationship to my father,’ he said.
‘Did you have a good relationship with him?’
‘May father died when I was twelve,’ he said. ‘I don’t think he ever told me that he loved me. He wasn’t that kind of man. He didn’t believe men should express their emotions.’
‘Maybe that’s why you’re writing this screenplay,’ she said. ‘To make him say it. Through your writing.’
‘You never speak of your father, I’ve noticed. I’ve heard a lot about your sisters and your mother, but never your father.’
She didn’t say anything, sipped her wine.
‘It’s not something you like to talk about?’
‘My father and I have nothing to say to one another,’ she said. ‘Silence can be an agreement, too.’
. . . . . .
The film does nothing to improve his mood. If anything, it only makes things worse. Twice he almost walked out. It hit a little too close to home. However, he perseveres and makes it to the end.
He walks out of the theater, his pace slowed by the romantic stroll of the couple ahead of him, their arms around one another. They pause to kiss. He tries to get around them. It’s as if the universe is mocking him. This is what love can do to you.
When he finally reaches the street, he walks in the direction of Rue des Écoles. There’s a café nearby that he likes to frequent. It doesn’t take his mind off Claire, though. He had wanted to take her there. As he walks down the Rue Champollion, his head lowered against the windswept rain, he thinks about writing a screenplay based in Paris, perhaps drawing on his relationship to Claire, as much as there is one. Dispense with his life in Lima which served as the basis for his debut effort, and perhaps write something closer to Rohmer. That spark of inspiration slightly improves his mood.
The lone walk down the darkened narrow street never felt so oppressive.
Just before he reaches the end of the street, he feels his cellphone vibrate in his coat pocket. A voicemail from Claire. He ducks into a doorway to listen to it. The weight of the world suddenly lifts from his shoulders.
. . . . . .
They stop meeting at the café in Belleville. Now they meet outside cinemas.
As the weeks pass, they take in films by Bergman, Antonioni, Fellini, Tarkovsky, and Bresson. The dynamic between them has shifted. Though there still hasn’t been intimacy of any sort, he can sense something is different. She makes more of an effort now. She often takes the initiative in wanting to see him. She calls more often. The text messages and social media shares increase. There is a sense that things are starting to turn around, but at her deliberate pace, at her own time and choosing. He knows from past mistakes to not push it. Just allow things to be. They do not discuss anything deeply personal. Only occasionally does Claire decide to lower the drawbridge across the mote, forcing him to piece together the story which she tries so hard to obscure. He is still an open book, however. He can’t help himself.
. . . . . .
They are showing a triple feature of early Truffaut at Le Champo. They are to meet out front.
It’s a cold evening. The quarter is festooned with the glow of holiday lights. One senses snow is coming. He arrives first, standing out in front of the theater with his hands buried deep in his coat pockets. Though things have been good over the past few weeks, he still worries that her Aquarian nature will resurface and she won’t show up. It wouldn’t be the first time. His anxiety intensifies. He paces around in front of the theater, repeatedly checking his cellphone for the time and to see if there are any texts from her. Nothing. It’s getting late. It’s almost showtime.
She arrives with a few minutes to spare. They purchase their tickets and enter the theater.
The only available seats are in the center of the back row. They settle in just as the lights dim and the first flicker of the coming attractions begin. The theater smells of buttered popcorn and Claire’s perfume. They sit with their shoulders pressed together. They do not speak, but when Claire does say something, it is accompanied by a light affectionate touch.
The program begins. They still don’t speak, each of them fully engrossed in the films. They occasionally whisper to one another about a particular shot, or how they admire the framing of a scene. They both seen these films dozens of times yet it is as if they are experiencing it for the first. There is a certain lightness between them, having left their burdens behind at the ticket booth.
. . . . . .
By the time the program ends it is late in the evening. The temperature has dropped considerably. A light snow kisses their faces as they walk down the Rue des Ècoles. It’s too late for coffee. Claire just wants to go home. Miguel offers to walk with her to the metro. He enters the station with her. He decides to wait for the train with her. They only speak of the films they saw. Nothing personal is exchanged. Claire suddenly moves closer to him. She momentarily rests her head on his shoulder. He breathes in the scent of her fading perfume. It’s a scent he now specifically identifies with her. The station is cold. A hint of vapor escapes Claire’s lips when she speaks. There is a brief moment where it feels as if she’s going to kiss him, but the arrival of the train spoils the moment. Instead she kisses him on the cheek and boards the train. He watches the train disappear into the tunnel. It’s suddenly very quiet.
. . . . . .
A few days before Christmas it begins to snow. Miguel stays home, writes an essay on Antonioni’s L’Avventura for his website, then makes notes for his potential Paris screenplay. He wants to write about the Antonioni film while it’s still fresh in his mind. He had gone out to see it again, the night before, but he saw it alone. He invited Claire but she never responded to him. He’d become used to these absences, these moments of retreat. Their relationship is better understood now, even if that understanding includes the realization that nothing was ever going to come of it. Still, he can’t help feel that she harbored deeper feelings for him. Something prevented her from taking the leap. It was in the eyes. It’s always in the eyes.
The snowfall intensifies. He continues to write. He had given up hope that she will call him, never mind wanting to see him. He thought about heading over to the cinema to catch a one day showing of Pasolini’s Mamma Roma, but the weather isn’t conducive to venturing out, even for a Pasolini film.
Then, out of the blue, Claire calls. She wants to go out.
He suggests the Pasolini film but she doesn’t want to see a film. She wants to take a walk. They agree to meet on the Quai de Montbello, across from the café.
Surprisingly, she arrives first. She’s leaning against the wall at the top of the stairs leading down to the quai. Her blonde hair flows from under her beige ski hat. Snow has collected on the shoulders of her tweed coat and Tibetan-styled mittens and matching scarf. Seeing her standing there, smiling and waving, is the only reason why he was willing to venture out of the apartment on an afternoon like this. He approaches her with a quickened pace. A grey sky hovers over the Seine. Snow had begun to accumulate on the ground around her tiny Doc Marten’s. She greets him with a hug and a kiss to the cheek.
‘Let’s walk by the river,’ she says.
They stroll along the quai, mostly making small talk. They discuss the possibility of ducking into the cinema to catch the Pasolini film, after all.
‘I think they only showed it in Lima once,’ he tells her. ‘It was the only time I ever saw it on the big screen. I have the DVD. That’s how I usually see it. I would love to see it in a theater again. I saw it with my brother, who didn’t appreciate it. Found it boring. Imagine? But that’s my brother. He doesn’t believe in anything but money and material things. I would really love to see it with you.’
‘Maybe,’ she says. ‘I’d really just like to walk.’
‘I miss that little theater in Lima,’ he says. ‘It was in Miraflores. It’s a trendy sort of area. I saw some of Kiarostami’s films there. My brother hated that too.’
‘At least you had someone to go with,’ she says. ‘None of my friends wanted to see the films I liked. I’d sometimes go with my father. He absolutely loved Jean Renoir. He used to take me to see them when I was a teenager.’
‘I’m surprised you brought him up. You never talk about him.’
‘He committed suicide,’ she says. ‘That’s why we no longer speak. But we stopped communicating long before that.’
‘I’m sorry,’ he says. ‘I had no idea…’
‘How could you know? I’ve been thinking about him lately, though I don’t know why. I’ve no good reason to. I suppose it’s the holidays. There are some pleasant memories, in spite of it all.’
They continue down the quai in silence, walking side by side, their hands in their pockets. Beads of wet snow pepper the back of her hair, a brilliant yellow against the dark brown tweed. He wants to put his arm around her, to comfort her, to kiss her. She mentioned her father’s suicide in such a matter-of-fact way, he doesn’t think she needs comforting.
. . . . . .
Christmas passes. Then New Year’s Day. Not a word from Claire.
She never answered his holiday greetings. Again, he attributes it to her Aquarian disposition. He can’t help wonder if that conversation about her father had something to do with it. He does his best to carry on — work, his essays, his screenplays. He mostly stays home, watches his favorite films on DVD, trying to figure out ways to write about them.
Another two weeks pass.
He occasionally sends her texts and periodically calls her to let her know he’s thinking of her. To no avail. Deep down, he knows she’ll reappear. When she’s ready.
. . . . . .
It isn’t until early March when Claire calls him out of the blue.
They agree to meet outside Le Reflet Médicis, where they are showing a new film by an emerging Italian director.
On the metro en route to the Latin Quarter, it occurs to him just how alone he is. No friends, no socializing with coworkers, no romantic prospects other than Claire, he second guesses his decision to come to Paris. As much as he needed to flee Lima, at least there he wasn’t alone. He’d been thinking about it a lot since he mentioned that theater in Miraflores, and his brother, who he hasn’t spoke to since coming to Paris. During his frequent sojourns down the rabbit hole, a nostalgia for his youth crept in. Things were easier then and perhaps not as bad as he remembered. He envisioned a new life, one of freedom, of abundance, out new attachments, new possibilities, and most importantly, a new self. All he’s done was transfer everything to another location.
Claire waits for him under the theater’s quasi-art deco styled marquee, dressed in a black leather blazer, black turtleneck sweater, and dark blue jeans. Her long mane seemed longer than the last time he saw her. She stands out from the rest of those waiting to enter the theater. She doesn’t react when she sees him approach her. Neutral. As if they had just seen one another a few hours ago.
‘It’s sold out,’ she says.
‘You’re kidding me.’
‘I wish I was. I looked forward to seeing it.’
‘What about the next showing?’
‘I have a better idea,’ she says. ‘I want to show you something.’
She starts walking down the Rue Champollion.
‘Where are we going?’
‘Just follow me,’ she says.
They ride the metro to Belleville. They hardly say two words to one another, but occasionally she smiles at him and lightly touches his arm.
They exit the metro and she leads him past the shuttered markets and unassuming apartment houses. She stops before a door covered in half-torn, faded movie posters. She removes a set of keys from her coat pocket and unlocks the door.
They step inside and Claire turns on the lights. An old storage room of sorts. Shelves of old VHS tapes, stacks of DVDs, and old film canisters reveals itself. A heavy odor of dust and mildew permeates the air.
‘My father’s collection,’ she says.
On a table, towards the back of the room, an old 16mm film projector. Directly across from it, a dusty, aged projection screen.
‘What is all this?’
‘My father used to own a cinema,’ she says. ‘He was like us. He lived and breathed cinema. This is everything he owned. This is all he left me.’
Miguel browses the titles of the countless VHS tapes lined up along the shelves. They are all here — Fellini, Godard, Antonioni, Bresson, Rohmer, Kubrick, Bergman, Tarkovsky, Kurosawa. It is nothing short of a temple to cinema. Miguel looks at her, questions her with his eyes.
‘I’ve been going through all this stuff the past couple of weeks,’ she says, ‘trying to sort it out and straighten up. I made some progress, trying to make the space more presentable. Everything was all over the place, disorganized. Essentially a dumping ground. I thought I’d better clean it up.’
‘How come you never mentioned this?’
‘It wasn’t something I wanted to talk about,’ she says.
She wanders about the space, looking around, as if trying to figure out how to further organize it. She turns to him and gestures towards a love seat, its brown leather cracked, creased, and torn. She pulls one of the 16mm reels from the shelf and opens the canister.
‘Please, sit,’ she says.
Miguel sits on the love seat. A puff of dust launches into the air. Claire threads the film into the projector, then walks across the room to line up the projection screen.
She turns on the projector, turns off the lights, and sits beside him.
‘I’m sure you’re going to love this,’ she says.
The countdown flickers across the screen.
Hiroshima Mon Amour.
Its 16mm print is scratched and faded. Occasional burn marks flicker across the screen. Its sound is muffled and distorted. Miguel looks at her. He doesn’t know what to say.
‘He used to show these films in the house when I was growing up,’ she says. ‘That’s how I came to love cinema. It was a special time. But it wasn’t enough. Nothing is ever enough. Do you ever have the feeling that nothing will ever be enough again?’
He doesn’t now how to answer that. There’s no need to talk. At the halfway point of the film she looks at him. He senses he’s being watched. He looks at her. She draws her lips towards his. She kisses him. They don’t see the rest of the film.
. . . . . .
In the days that follow, they continue to meet. Everything changed, yet nothing did. It was as if what happened in the old storage room was nothing more than one of his rabbit hole fantasies. There is no mention of the kiss, and when he attempted to kiss her again, she turns away.
‘No, please…’, is all she says.
They try to carry on as before but something is different.
Time passes. Paris grows warmer. The spring rains have subsided. On their frequent outings, it seems as if they are just going through the motions, pretending what happened between them never did. Yet it continues to linger between them, like a shirt which refuses to detach itself. The pendulum continues to swing this way and that, from presence to absence, from affectionate to cold and distant.
He tries to ride it out, taking each day as it comes, but there are many continued sojourns down the rabbit hole. He can’t sleep, can’t focus on his work.
She disappears for weeks on end, then suddenly reappears as if her absence lasted only a moment. He attempts to talk to her about what happened between them but whenever he tries, the pendulum swings the other way.
He tries to give her the space she needs, even though it is slowly killing him inside. He yearns for those good moments, when she is present.
Then the pendulum ultimately swings towards him again.
He knows he has to let it go, give up the ghost, but he loves her, perhaps a little too much.
Then one day they agree to meet outside Le Grand Action on the Rue des Ècoles. It was another chance to see that Italian film they missed a few months earlier.
She doesn’t show up.
He calls her. No answer.
Days pass. Then a week. Then another.
Again, out of the blue she sends him a text message: I can’t anymore. It’s not you. It’s this. All of this.
He has no idea what it means.
It’s a brutal summer. Hot, oppressive, lonely. He spends most of his time alone, writing his essays, building his website, and working on his new screenplay which is based on his encounter with Claire. He takes long walks through the city just to alleviate his sense of isolation, sometimes walking from the Seine to Montmartre, down through Bastille, and into Saint-Germain. He wanders the city much like the characters in the films he always loved, those films he and Claire often saw together. He finds new cinemas to frequent, out of the way spaces on the edges of Paris, as far away from Claire’s ghost as possible. He uses all of it, though, for his screenwriting. When he’s not acting the flaneur, he spends his time creating a world of his own. The world of cinema. A world in which he feels he truly belongs.
